Straight answers
What is multi-carrier quoting?
Multi-carrier quoting is getting quotes on the same risk from several carriers at once so you can compare price and coverage before you place the business. Agencies do it two ways. A comparative rater takes one data entry and returns rates from the carriers it integrates with, which is fast but limited to supported carriers and lines. Portal automation works the carrier portals directly, which reaches the carriers a rater does not cover but has traditionally meant typing the same application into each portal one at a time.
| Approach | How it works | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Comparative rater (EZLynx, PL Rating, Tarmika, QuoteRush) | One data entry returns rates from integrated carriers | Only the carriers and lines the rater supports |
| Carrier portals directly | Log in and key the application into each carrier | Reaches every appointed carrier, but 15 to 20 minutes per portal for personal lines |
| Portal automation (Relay AI Quoting, Research Preview) | Runs configured portal workflows across selected carriers from one reviewed submission | Preview status. The agency selects supported carriers and a person reviews results |
The longer version
The point of quoting many carriers is comparison. Placing a client with the first carrier you check leaves money and coverage on the table, and it is how independent agencies earn the word independent. Multi-carrier quoting is the mechanism: line up the appointed carriers with appetite for the risk, quote them, and show the client a real choice.
The coverage gap is where it gets hard. Comparative raters are mature for personal lines and small commercial on API-connected carriers, but most agencies also carry appointed carriers that are portal-only. Those are the ones that eat the day. Agencies report 15 to 20 minutes per carrier portal for personal lines, and more for commercial, per Relay's published quoting cost math. Multiply that by the carriers a rater does not cover and you see why quoting stalls.
Portal automation is the other route, and this is where Relay fits, honestly scoped. AI Quoting is a Research Preview that runs configured portal workflows across the carriers an agency selects, in parallel, with a person reviewing every result. It does not replace a rater. It reaches the portal-only carriers a rater cannot. Relay published a carrier portal automation benchmark (June 2026, HO-3 new business) with field accuracy and time measurements, which is the kind of evidence worth asking any vendor in this category to produce.
Common questions
Is a comparative rater the same as multi-carrier quoting?
A rater is one way to do it. It returns rates from the carriers it integrates with. Carriers outside the rater still require the portal, which is where portal automation comes in.
How many carriers should I quote?
Enough to give the client a real comparison, usually the appointed carriers with appetite for that risk. The limit is usually time, not desire, because each portal-only carrier adds 15 to 20 minutes of manual entry for personal lines.
Is Relay a comparative rater?
No. Relay's AI Quoting is a Research Preview that automates the carrier portal workflows an agency selects, with human review. It reaches portal-only carriers a rater does not cover rather than replacing your rater.
Related questions
Part of the Relay straight answers library. Updated 2026-07-11. See how we source content.
Get started
Get on the Summer ’26 list.
Spring ’26 is full. Get on the Summer ’26 list and we will be in touch as spots open.