Choosing a comparative rater for your agency
A large carrier logo list is a starting point. The useful question is whether a rater returns usable results for the carriers, lines, states, and risks your agency writes.
Test familiar accounts across your shortlist. Record which markets return an indication or quote, what questions remain, whether the bridge works, and how the team finishes the comparison. That reveals more than a generic best-rater ranking.
Side by side
How the two paths compare
| Option | Published focus | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| EZLynx Rating Engine | Personal lines comparative rating | Your appointed markets and the complete quoting path |
| Vertafore PL Rating | Personal lines comparative rating | Supported risk details, carrier results, and AMS handoff |
| QuoteRush | Home and auto rating connections | Current product scope, state support, and carrier completion steps |
| Tarmika | Commercial quoting across participating markets | The lines, classes, carrier access, and questions for your book |
Where each fits
When a comparative rater fits
The central need is comparing pricing across supported markets from one set of information.
Your appointed carriers and the relevant line and state combinations are supported.
You have tested the remaining carrier questions and steps through a usable result.
Where Relay fits
You still need to prepare applicant details from client documents before starting the rater.
You have carrier workflows outside the rater that Relay can specifically support.
Your team needs to turn received quotes into a proposal with clear differences and source terms.
The honest take
What we would tell a friend who runs an agency
Measure both sides of the rater. Before it, the team may be reading dec pages and building application data. After it, they may be checking terms and preparing a proposal. Relay can be evaluated on those defined tasks.
For a browser quoting workflow, confirm the exact carrier, line, state, authentication, and required actions during setup. Review the result status and outstanding questions. Product support should be proven on your account type, not inferred from a logo.
FAQ
Common questions
Which rater has the most carriers?+
Published totals may count different products, states, or connections. Build a list of the markets you actually use and ask each vendor to confirm those combinations.
Are comparative rates final quotes?+
Result status varies. Check reports, outstanding underwriting questions, quote conditions, expiration, and the steps required to bind.
Can one rater handle personal and commercial lines?+
Some providers offer multiple products or lines. Ask for a demonstration of your specific personal and commercial workflows and confirm what is included in the agreement.
Sources
Part of the Relay comparison library. Updated 2026-07-11.
Your next step starts with one email.
Join the waitlist. We’re inviting agencies regularly and will email you when access is available.
Join the waitlist