Buyer's guide
Best comparative raters for insurance agencies (2026)
A comparative rater does one job well: enter the risk once, get prices back from many carriers at once, and compare coverage side by side instead of quoting each carrier by hand. Personal lines is where raters shine. Commercial is thinner, and specialty thinner still.
The names you will actually shortlist: EZLynx, PL Rating, and TurboRater for personal lines, plus Tarmika and Semsee for small commercial. None of them publish pricing, so plan on a demo for every quote. Here is how they line up, and where an automation tool like Relay fits, which is not as a rater.
Side by side
How the two paths compare
| EZLynx Rating Engine | PL Rating | TurboRater | Tarmika | Semsee | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lines | Personal (home, auto) | Personal | Personal (home, auto, flood) | Small commercial | Small commercial (BOP) |
| Carriers (per vendor) | 330+, 48 states | 300+ | Hundreds | Not published | 50+ |
| AMS tie | Bundled in EZLynx AMS | Standalone, integrates 20+ systems | Part of Zywave's personal lines suite | Standalone, now part of Applied | Standalone |
| Pricing | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published | Not published |
Where each fits
When a comparative rater fits
You quote personal lines at volume. Enter the home or auto risk once and a rater returns prices from a wide panel. EZLynx cites 330+ carriers across 48 states and more than 13 million quotes a month, and Vertafore calls PL Rating the industry's top personal lines rater with 300+ carriers.
You want quoting and management in one bill. EZLynx bundles the rater into its AMS, and QQ Catalyst pairs with PL Rating. If you would rather keep the rater separate, PL Rating integrates with AMS360, QQ Catalyst, and 20+ other management systems.
You write small commercial. Tarmika and Semsee bring single-entry quoting to BOP, workers comp, and general liability, the lines that used to mean logging into carrier portals one at a time. Tarmika is now part of Applied Systems, and Semsee lists 50+ carriers for small commercial.
Speed is the point. Vertafore says PL Rating cuts personal lines quoting time by up to half. A rater earns its keep when quoting volume is your bottleneck.
Where Relay fits
Relay is not a comparative rater. It holds no carrier price connections and does not compare quotes side by side, so it does not replace EZLynx, PL Rating, or the rest. Keep your rater.
The work around the quote is where Relay lives: reading the client's documents into structured data (Document Parsing, live), drafting the ACORD forms (ACORD Generation, live), and triaging the submission inbox (Ask Relay, live).
For carriers no rater connects to, and there are many in commercial and specialty, Relay's AI Quoting is a Research Preview that preps carrier portal work for a licensed person to review. It is not a live rater and should not be counted as one when you compare tools today.
Other paths
Alternatives worth weighing
Bold Penguin
A commercial insurance exchange plus its Terminal platform. Bold Penguin says it powers distribution for 8 of the top 10 commercial carriers.
Best for: Small commercial and E&S where you want market access and routing, not just a price grid.
Carrier direct portals
The no-rater path: log into each carrier and quote by hand.
Best for: Commercial and specialty carriers that no comparative rater connects to.
An AMS with rating built in
EZLynx combines the AMS and a personal lines rater, so quoting and management share one login and one bill.
Best for: Personal lines shops that do not want a separate rater vendor.
The honest take
What we would tell a friend who runs an agency
A comparative rater and Relay solve different halves of the same job. The rater gets you prices. Relay handles the paperwork and the inbox around them. Relay is not a rater: it has no carrier price connections and does not compare quotes. What it does, live, is read the documents clients send (Document Parsing), draft the ACORD forms nobody wants to re-key (ACORD Generation), and triage the submission thread (Ask Relay). AI Quoting, which preps carrier portal workflows for human review, is a Research Preview and not a substitute for a rater. If quoting personal lines volume is your bottleneck, buy a rater. If re-keying and portal-hopping around the quote is the bottleneck, that is Relay's half.
FAQ
Common questions
Is Relay a comparative rater?+
No. Relay does not connect to carriers for prices and does not compare quotes side by side. It handles the work around the quote: reading documents (Document Parsing), drafting ACORD forms (ACORD Generation), and inbox triage (Ask Relay), all live. Its AI Quoting is a Research Preview, not a rater.
Do these raters cover commercial lines?+
Personal lines raters like EZLynx, PL Rating, and TurboRater focus on home and auto. For commercial, Tarmika and Semsee cover small commercial such as BOP, workers comp, and general liability. Complex and specialty commercial often still requires quoting in each carrier's own portal.
What do comparative raters cost?+
None of the major raters publish pricing on their websites. EZLynx, PL Rating, TurboRater, Tarmika, and Semsee all route you to a sales quote based on your lines, states, and volume. Plan on a demo before you see a number.
Personal lines rater versus commercial rater, what is the difference?+
Personal lines raters connect to a wide panel of home and auto carriers and return prices fast, because those carriers publish rates to raters in bulk. Commercial raters like Tarmika and Semsee handle small commercial, where carrier connections are fewer and the application is longer. The larger and more specialized the commercial risk, the more likely you still quote it directly with the carrier.
Sources
Part of the Relay comparison library. Updated 2026-07-11.
Get started
Get on the Summer ’26 list.
Spring ’26 is full. Get on the Summer ’26 list and we will be in touch as spots open.